For earthquake warnings, look to ... toads?

Finally, scientists have found a tool to provide early warning of earthquakes: it's a small, brown, knobbly amphibian.
The researchers think toads flee in response to pre-seismic cues such as changes in the ionosphere, according to a study published in the Journal of Zoology.
The male common toad (Bufo bufo) gave five days' warning of the earthquake that ravaged the town of L'Aquila in central Italy on April 6, 2009, killing more than 300 people and displacing 40,000 others, they wrote.

Male toads flee site before quake

Biologist Rachel Grant of Britain's Open University embarked on a toad-monitoring project at San Ruffino Lake, 74 km north of L'Aquila, 10 days before the 6.3-magnitude quake.
Her two-person team observed the site for 29 days, counting toad numbers and measuring temperature, humidity, wind speed, rainfall and other conditions.
By March 28, more than 90 male toads had mustered for the spawning season, but two days later, their numbers suddenly fell, Grant reports. By April 1 - five days before the quake - 96% of the males had fled.

Return after last aftershock

Several dozen ventured back on April 9 for the full moon, a known courtship period for toads, although the tally was some 50-80% fewer than in previous years.
After this small peak, the numbers fell once more, only picking up significantly on April 15, two days after the last major aftershock, defined as 4.5 magnitude or higher.
In addition, the number of paired toads at the breeding site also dropped to zero three days before the quake. And no fresh spawn was found at the site from April 6 until the last big after-tremor.

Five days before the 6.3-magnitude earthquake

in L'Aquila in central Italy, toad numbers

suddenly dropped.

Credit: Wikimedia

Unusual behaviour

Grant says the toads' comportment is a "dramatic change" for the species. Once male toads hole up at a breeding site, they usually never leave until the annual spawning season is over, she notes.

Eager to answer the riddle, Grant obtained Russian measurements of electrical activity in the ionosphere, the uppermost electromagnetic layer in the atmosphere, which were picked up by very low frequency (VLF) radio receivers.

The toads' two periods of exodus both coincided with bursts of VLF disruption.

Previous research has attributed perturbations in the ionosphere to releases of radon, a radioactive gas generated underground, or to gravity waves prior to a quake, although much about this phenomenon is unclear.

Pre-seismic clues: gases and charged particles

In the quest to find an earthquake predictor, elephants, horses, wolves, snakes and fish have all been variously put forward.
This study, though, is exceptional. It puts the flesh of data and first-hand observation on the bones of anecdotal evidence, even if there is no confirmed explanation as to why the toads bolted as they did.
"Our study is one of the first to document animal behaviour before, during and after an earthquake," says Grant.
"Our findings suggest that toads are able to detect pre-seismic cues such as the release of gases and charged particles, and use these as a form of early warning system."


Agence France-Presse